Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

15 Things Every American Kid Remembers About Learning Long Division in 1966 That Schools No Longer Teach

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

In 1966 long division was the first thing at school that was genuinely hard. Addition, subtraction and multiplication could all be managed by a child who was paying attention; this one could not. It required a dozen operations in sequence, each depending on the result of the last, with no way to check any of them until the end – and a guess in the middle that felt to every child like cheating. Here are fifteen things every American kid remembers about learning long division in 1966, and why schools no longer teach it the way they did.

1. It Was the First Thing at School That Was Genuinely Hard

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Addition, subtraction and multiplication could all be managed by a child who was paying attention, and this one could not.

The step up was real rather than a matter of presentation. Long division is the first procedure a child meets that requires holding several operations in sequence, each depending on the result of the last, with no way to check any of them until the end.

That is why it is remembered so specifically. Almost everybody who went through it can say where they were sitting and what the page looked like, which is not true of the arithmetic that came before, and the reason is simply that this was the first time school had been difficult.


Like our content? Follow us for more.

2. The Layout on the Page Was Half the Problem

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Getting the figures in the right columns, in the right order, with everything lined up, was a requirement before any arithmetic happened at all.

The spatial demand is easy to forget. A child who understood every step perfectly could still fail entirely because their columns had drifted, their working had wandered across the page or they had run out of room halfway down and continued somewhere else.

Teachers therefore marked the layout as well as the answer. A correct result reached on a disorganised page was frequently returned for doing again, which struck children as deeply unfair and was in fact the single most useful thing anybody taught them about it.

3. You Had to Guess, and Guessing Felt Like Cheating

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

The procedure requires estimating how many times one number goes into another, which is an informed guess rather than a calculation.

The guessing is the part nobody explains properly. Everything school had taught up to that point produced a definite answer by a definite method, and here was a step where the child had to try something, test it, and go back if it was wrong.

Children found that genuinely disorienting. A great many concluded that they were doing it incorrectly precisely because it felt like approximation, and the ones who got on with it fastest were the ones who had somehow understood that trying and adjusting was the method rather than a failure of it.

4. The Working Had to Be Shown and That Was Not Negotiable

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

An answer without the working underneath it earned no credit, however correct it happened to be.

The rule existed for a defensible reason. A long division cannot be done in the head reliably, which means an answer with no working is either copied or lucky, and a teacher with thirty papers had no other way of telling which.

It also made the failure legible. A child who had shown their working had a visible record of exactly where they had gone wrong, which is the entire educational point of the requirement and was not explained to anybody at the time.

5. One Error Anywhere Destroyed Everything After It

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Because each step feeds the next, a mistake in the second line made every subsequent line wrong regardless of how well it was executed.

The cascade is what made the subject so demoralising. A child could perform eleven operations perfectly and one incorrectly and arrive at an answer with no relationship to the right one, having done almost all of the work properly.

Finding the error was its own skill. Going back through a page of working to locate the single line where it went wrong is a diagnostic exercise nobody had taught, and children developed their own methods for it entirely by necessity.

6. The Remainder Was a Concept Nobody Had Prepared You For

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Arithmetic had always come out exactly, and suddenly there was something left over that had to be written down and accounted for.

The novelty was conceptual rather than procedural. A number that does not divide cleanly introduces the idea that an answer can be incomplete and still correct, which is a genuinely new thought for a nine-year-old.

It was also the commonest place to lose marks. Forgetting the remainder, writing it in the wrong place or treating it as part of the answer accounted for an enormous proportion of the errors on any set of papers.

7. Scrap Paper Was Both Essential and Frowned Upon

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

The calculation generated working that had to go somewhere, and the attitude to where varied completely between classrooms.

The tension was never resolved. Some teachers insisted everything appear on the page in order, some provided rough paper and some regarded any additional working as evidence that the child had not learned the method properly.

Children adapted to whichever rule applied. A child who moved between teachers discovered that the same work was praised in one room and corrected in another, which is an early and useful lesson in the difference between a subject and the person teaching it.

8. Multiplication Tables Were the Hidden Prerequisite

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

The procedure is impossible at speed for a child who does not have the tables available instantly, and everybody discovered that simultaneously.

The dependency explains the misery. A child who had got by with slow recall could manage simple arithmetic and could not manage this, because every step requires a product immediately and there is no time to work one out.

It caused a late and unwelcome reckoning. Children who had quietly avoided learning the tables properly found that out in the middle of something else entirely, which is why the two subjects are remembered as a single unpleasant period.

9. The Blackboard Demonstration Went Too Fast for Almost Everybody

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

A teacher working an example on the board moved at the speed of somebody who already knew the answer.

The mismatch was structural. An expert demonstrating a sequence they have performed thousands of times cannot easily reproduce the pace of a person meeting it for the first time, and the children were watching rather than doing.

Understanding only arrived with a pencil. Almost nobody learned this from a demonstration; they learned it from the fourth or fifth attempt at their own desk, which means the board work served mainly as a reference rather than as instruction.

10. Asking for Help Was Socially Expensive

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Putting a hand up to say you did not understand announced it to a room of people who were pretending they did.

The cost was a consequence of the difficulty. When a topic defeats a substantial fraction of the class, admitting to being defeated by it separates you from everybody who is concealing the same thing, which almost everybody was.

Most children therefore said nothing. The usual strategy was to produce something that looked like working and hope the error was small, which is why so many people reached adulthood with an incomplete understanding they had never disclosed.

11. Somebody in Every Class Simply Got It

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

One or two children picked it up immediately and were used as evidence that it was not difficult.

The comparison was unhelpful and unavoidable. A class in which somebody finishes in two minutes is a class in which everybody else’s struggle looks like a deficiency rather than a normal response to a hard procedure.

Those children were rarely good at explaining it. A person who has not experienced the difficulty cannot identify where somebody else is stuck, which is why help from the front of the class was usually less useful than help from the child one desk over who had just worked it out.

12. Homework Turned It Into a Household Problem

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Division sent home at nine years old involved whichever adult was available, with results that varied enormously.

The variation came from method rather than ability. Adults had learned the procedure in different decades, with different layouts and different conventions, and an adult explaining their own version to a child being taught another produced a worse outcome than no help at all.

That was the first subject where that happened. Up to that point a parent could assist with anything school had set, and this is where a great many households discovered that they could no longer simply help.

13. Getting One Right Was a Disproportionate Triumph

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

A single completed long division, checked and correct, produced a sense of achievement out of all proportion to the task.

The reaction was appropriate to the effort. A procedure with a dozen dependent steps and no feedback until the end offers nothing at all until it offers everything, which makes the moment of completion unusually satisfying.

It is the one positive memory almost everybody keeps. People who disliked the whole subject still remember the first one they got right without help, which says something about how rarely school of that period produced that particular feeling.

14. The Method Was Taught as the Only Way to Do It

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Alternative approaches, estimation and anything resembling a shortcut were treated as errors rather than as other routes.

The rigidity had a practical justification. Thirty children following one procedure can be taught, marked and corrected consistently, and thirty children each using their own method cannot, whatever the merits of any individual approach.

It also closed off understanding for some. A child whose own way of thinking about division was perfectly sound but did not match the taught layout was marked wrong, and a proportion of those children concluded they could not do arithmetic at all.

15. Then the Calculation Stopped Being Done by Hand

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Cheap calculators, computers and a complete reconsideration of what arithmetic a child needs to perform manually removed the procedure from most of its old prominence.

Nobody should pretend this is a loss. The ability to divide large numbers on paper is of almost no practical use to anybody now, and the time it consumed is far better spent on understanding what division is for.

What went with it is a particular experience of difficulty. A nine-year-old, a sheet of paper, a dozen steps each depending on the last, a guess in the middle that felt like cheating, an answer that could be destroyed by a single line, and a room full of children none of whom were willing to say they were lost.

Why This One Was Different

long division
Source: Wikimedia Commons 

Read in order, the fifteen all come back to the same structural fact: this was the first procedure where the steps depended on each other. That produced the cascade, where eleven perfect operations and one wrong one give an answer with no relationship to the right one. It produced the demand for shown working, because an answer with no working is either copied or lucky and a teacher with thirty papers had no other way to tell. It produced the layout requirement, which children thought was pedantry and was in fact the most useful thing anybody taught them about it, because columns that drift make the cascade impossible to trace.

Three things made it harder than it needed to be. The guess in the middle, which nobody explained as the method rather than a failure of it. The multiplication tables, which the procedure assumes are instantly available and which a great many children had quietly never learned properly – a reckoning that arrived in the middle of something else entirely. And the social cost of admitting to being lost in a room where a substantial fraction of the class was concealing exactly the same thing, which is why so many people reached adulthood with an incomplete understanding they had never disclosed to anybody.

Nobody should pretend the change is a loss. The ability to divide large numbers on paper is of almost no practical use to anybody now, and the hours it consumed are better spent on what division is actually for. The modern position on this is correct.

What went with it is a particular early experience of difficulty: a nine-year-old with a sheet of paper, a dozen steps each depending on the last, a guess in the middle that felt like cheating, an answer that one line could destroy, and the first one they ever got right without help – which is the single positive memory almost everybody who went through it still keeps.


Like our content? Follow us for more.