Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

16 Things the Soda Fountain Served in 1960 That No Soda Jerk Could Legally Make Now

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The American soda fountain is remembered as a social institution, which it was, and as a food business, which it also was. The second half is the interesting one. Because the fountain sat inside a drugstore, a few feet from a dispensary, it operated across a boundary that no longer exists, and a surprising number of its standard items were somewhere between a drink and a medicine.

What follows is a mixture. Some items are prohibited outright, and the prohibition usually has a date attached. Others are barred by the modern food code rather than by any ban on an ingredient, which is the less dramatic and more comprehensive reason a 1960 fountain could not reopen tomorrow. A few are simply gone, and in at least one case the modern version is worse and everybody knows it. Here are sixteen fountain items that have gone, and what took each of them away.

1. Root beer and sarsaparilla flavoured with real sassafras

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The old fountain syrups for root beer and sarsaparilla took their characteristic flavour from sassafras root bark, and the better fountains made their own from extract. It is the flavour people mean when they say modern root beer tastes thinner than they remember.

The active compound, safrole, was prohibited as a food additive by the Food and Drug Administration in 1960 on the basis of animal carcinogenicity findings. Sassafras oil went out of the food supply, and the commercial root beers were reformulated with safrole-free extract and other flavourings.

This is the cleanest prohibition on the list and it falls exactly at the start of the decade. A fountain operating in 1960 was working through the transition; a 1958 root beer and a 1962 root beer were different products with the same name.

Like our content? Follow us for more.

2. Drinks with a raw egg broken into them

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The egg phosphate and the egg malted were standard fountain items, and the egg was a real one, cracked into the mixing cup in front of the customer. It was sold as a restorative and ordered by people who had missed a meal.

Current American food safety practice requires pasteurised eggs for any preparation served without cooking, and a raw shell egg dropped into a beverage for a general customer is not permissible. The equivalent drinks that survive are made with pasteurised product or with no egg at all.

The egg cream, confusingly, never contained egg and is unaffected. It is one of the few fountain drinks that can still be made exactly as it was, which may be why it is the one that has survived best.

3. Coca-Cola syrup dispensed as a remedy for an upset stomach

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Fountain operators sold plain syrup, undiluted or with a little soda, for nausea and indigestion. It was asked for by name, it was sometimes recommended by the pharmacist on the other side of the same shop, and it was understood as a mild medicine.

A food or beverage sold with a claim to treat a condition is a drug under American law, and selling it that way without authorisation is not available to anyone now. The practice survives only as a piece of household folklore passed between grandmothers.

The fountain’s position inside a drugstore is what made this possible and is the reason it looked unremarkable. The boundary between the two counters was a good deal less distinct in 1960 than the floor plan suggested.

4. Fizzy headache powders mixed at the counter

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Effervescent remedies for headache and hangover were dispensed and mixed at fountains, handed over in a glass, and drunk standing up. They were a volume product, particularly on a Sunday morning, and they were sold with the sodas rather than with the prescriptions.

Several of the best-known formulations were bromide-based. Bromides were removed from American over-the-counter products by the Food and Drug Administration in 1975 after accumulated-toxicity findings, and the surviving brands were reformulated around different ingredients entirely.

A modern pharmacy still sells the descendants of these products in a box. What has gone is the counter service: somebody measuring a dose into a glass of soda water for you and watching you drink it.

5. Soda charged by hand from a pressurised siphon

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The carbonation came from the operator. Water was charged under pressure on the premises, drawn off against the syrup, and the skill of the job was in the proportion and the pour — which is why the person doing it had a job title and some status.

Fountains now run on sealed post-mix systems with regulated gas, backflow prevention and documented cleaning schedules. The equipment is engineered so that the operator cannot vary the mix, which is both the safety improvement and the end of the craft.

Nothing was wrong with the old method in principle. What it lacked was a way to demonstrate that the lines had been cleaned, which is the whole of the modern requirement and the thing that hand-charged equipment could never produce.

6. Brightly coloured syrups using additives since delisted

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Cherry, lime and the various red and orange flavours depended on colour additives from a list that American regulators have substantially shortened. The colours were part of the appeal and they were vivid in a way that is now difficult to achieve.

Red No. 2 was banned by the Food and Drug Administration in 1976, and other additives permitted in 1960 have since been delisted. A fountain syrup made to a 1960 recipe would in several cases be illegal to serve on colour grounds alone.

This is why restored fountains that aim at authenticity cannot quite get there. The glassware, the fittings and the technique can be reproduced. The colour of a 1960 cherry phosphate cannot.

7. Wintergreen and birch flavours at their old strength

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Birch beer and wintergreen sodas were fountain staples, and the flavour comes from methyl salicylate. In the concentrations the old syrups used, it delivered a pungency that modern versions do not attempt.

Methyl salicylate is now restricted in food use, with limits on how much may be present, because it is toxic in quantity and the margin in a strongly flavoured syrup is narrower than anyone realised. The flavour survives; the strength does not.

Both of these are also regional. Birch beer has held on in parts of the northeastern United States in a way it has not elsewhere, which means the modern version is one of the few fountain flavours a curious drinker can still compare against the memory.

8. Ice cream made in the back and dipped by hand

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The better fountains froze their own, in a machine behind the counter, and dipped it with a scoop kept in a well of standing water. The scoop went back into the same water between customers and stayed there all day.

The dipper well is now required to be a running-water unit with a specified flow, precisely because a well of standing water at room temperature is an incubator. On-premises freezing is still permitted but has to be done under a licensed and inspected process.

Almost everything about hand-dipping survives in a modern ice cream shop. The one thing that does not is the water, and the change is a single plumbing fitting that nobody notices and that closed off the fountain’s most reliable hygiene failure.

9. Bare hands on everything

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The operator handled glasses, scoops, fruit, whipped cream, nuts, cherries and the customer’s change with the same two hands and a towel over the shoulder. The towel did duty as a cloth, a hand wipe and a glass polisher.

Current food codes require handwashing sinks within reach of the service area, bar hand contact with ready-to-eat food, and set out when gloves or utensils must be used. The shoulder towel is the single most photographed item in the whole trade and is now unusable.

It is worth being fair about this. Fountain operators were often fastidious, and the trade had its own standards about a clean counter. What it did not have was a written standard that an inspector could check, which is the difference the codes made.

10. Glasses washed in a single sink of water

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The sundae dishes and soda glasses went into one sink, were wiped, rinsed if there was time, and went back into service. On a busy afternoon the same water did a great many glasses.

American food service now requires a three-compartment arrangement for manual washing — wash, rinse, sanitise — or a machine that achieves the equivalent, with the sanitiser concentration checked and recorded. One sink does not meet any part of it.

This is the item that would close a 1960 fountain fastest in a modern inspection, ahead of anything in the syrups. It is also the one that nobody at the time regarded as a compromise, because the alternative had not been invented yet.

11. Lithium in the lemon-lime soda, within living memory

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The best-known American lemon-lime drink was formulated with lithium citrate when it was launched, which is where part of its original name came from, and it was marketed on mood-lifting grounds.

The lithium was removed in 1948, so a 1960 fountain was not serving it. It belongs on this list because the reformulation was within the working memory of the people behind the counter, and because it is the clearest case of a fountain ingredient that would now be a controlled pharmaceutical.

The soda is still sold, under the shortened name, with no lithium and no mood claim. Most people drinking it have no idea that the name is a fossil of the original formula.

12. Tonic with quinine at a strength that mattered

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Tonic water at the fountain carried quinine, and the older formulations carried enough of it to be noticeably bitter and, historically, to be sold on antimalarial grounds. It was a medicine that had become a mixer.

Quinine in American beverages is now capped at a low limit, and tonic water is a flavouring rather than a dose. Quinine as a drug has separately been restricted in the United States because of serious adverse effects, including a warning against its use for leg cramps.

The drink is one of the last survivors of an entire category — the tonic, the bitters, the restorative — that the fountain sold as something between a soft drink and a remedy, and that modern regulation split cleanly into two different shops.

13. Whipped cream made in the morning and left out

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

Cream was whipped in a batch at the start of the day and kept on the counter in a bowl under a cloth, scooped onto sundaes for hours. Refrigeration behind a 1960 counter was limited and cold storage was reserved for what needed it most.

Whipped dairy cream is a food requiring temperature control, and holding it unrefrigerated through a service period is not permissible. Modern counters dispense it from a pressurised refrigerated unit or whip to order in small quantities.

The old version was better, and everybody who remembers both says so. It is the clearest example on this list of a genuine loss rather than an improvement disguised as one, and the reason for the change is nonetheless sound.

14. Aromatic spirits of ammonia added to a Coke

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

This is the fountain order that modern readers refuse to believe. A dash of aromatic spirits of ammonia — smelling salts, essentially — was added to a Coke on request, and it was ordered as a pick-me-up and for headaches.

Aromatic spirits of ammonia is a pharmaceutical preparation and adding it to a beverage for a customer is not a thing any food business can do. It survives in a pharmacy as an inhalant and nowhere near a glass.

The order had a name at the counter and regular customers who used it. It is the single best illustration of what the drugstore fountain actually was: a food counter standing a few feet from a dispensary, with the staff moving freely between the two.

15. Cigarettes sold across the same counter

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The fountain and the tobacco display were frequently the same transaction, and the age controls on the second were weak to nonexistent. A child sent for a packet for a parent was an entirely ordinary errand.

American federal law now sets a minimum purchase age of 21 for tobacco, with identification requirements, retailer compliance checks and penalties. Tobacco sales in pharmacies specifically have been prohibited by a number of states and cities.

That last restriction is the one that would surprise a 1960 operator most. The combination of a soda fountain, a cigarette counter and a prescription dispensary under one roof was the standard American drugstore, and it is now illegal in that configuration in parts of the country.

16. No written anything

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

There were no recipes on file, no temperature logs, no cleaning schedules, no supplier records, no date marking on the prepared syrups and no allergen information. The knowledge was in the operator and the standards were in the proprietor’s judgement.

Every one of those is now a document. A food business is expected to be able to show what it did, when, and with what, and the inspection regime is built around the records rather than around a look at the counter.

This is the real difference and it is the hardest to feel nostalgic about in either direction. The fountain’s charm was that it was a personal operation run on craft and memory. That is also precisely what made it unverifiable.

The counter that stood between two trades

Soda Fountain
Source: Wikimedia

The thing to hold onto is the floor plan. In 1960 one American building routinely contained a dispensary filling prescriptions, a counter selling cigarettes to whoever was standing there, and a food service operation making drinks with raw eggs and pharmaceutical preparations in them, staffed by people who moved between all three.

Every boundary in that sentence has since been drawn. Food and drug claims were separated. Tobacco was age-restricted and in places removed from pharmacies entirely. Food service was brought under a written code with records and inspections. The soda fountain did not die of any single one of those; it died of all of them arriving at once, alongside the fast food restaurant and the home freezer, in a decade when the economics were already going against a counter that needed a skilled operator to produce a drink that a machine could make.

There are restored fountains operating in the United States and they are worth visiting, but it is worth knowing what they can and cannot give you. The counter, the glassware, the stools, the pour and the sound of it are all faithful. The root beer, the colours, the whipped cream and the egg drinks are not, because four of those are now illegal in their original form and one is merely impossible to keep on a counter all afternoon.

The building is the artefact. The menu is a reconstruction.

Like our content? Follow us for more.